Jel ovo novo ime ulice koje jos nije u RGZ-u?:) Kako si dosao da imena ulice?:)

Jasno, jasno. Samo unosi sta treba!:) Tu smo ako imas nekih pitanja oko OSM-a - koriscenja i menjanja. Na forumu https://community.openstreetmap.org/c/communities/rs/64 i na Telegramu na https://t.me/osm_sr

Zdravo!
Vidim da unosis imena ulica. Mozda ce ti znaciti da znas da postoji DINA sajt koji smo koristili da unesemo preostale i sredimo sve ulice u Srbiji: https://dina.openstreetmap.rs/. Tu mozes da vidis sve ulice, sta fali, da uporedis geometrije iz RGZ-a i u OSM-u. Imas i nase podloge gde mozes u editoru da vidis RGZ geometrije.

Samo da ti kazem da obicno pored imena ulice stavljamo i "int_name" (internacionalno ime, tj. ime bez nasih kvacica) i "ref:RS:ulica" (to je identifikacija ulice u RGZ-u kojom je "vezujemo" za adresni registar, pa onda mozemo da radimo razne analize i uocavamo greske).

Poz!

CK je od Crveni Krst? Dogovor je da ne stavljamo imena puteva koji su samo "od - do" jer je to jasno i to treba router da radi. Ako je ovo deo neke duze planinarske rute, javi da je ucrtamo kako treba!

Zdravo? Sta ti znaci ovo "CK"? Zvanicno RGZ nema ovo ime ulice, a ako je ovaj put deo neke planinarske rute, bolje je da se napravi relacija, posto se tako oznacavaju planinarske staze, vec smo dosta sredjivali ovde: osm.wiki/Serbia/Projekti/PSS_staze

Javi da vidim da li da brisemo ime puta ili da pravimo relaciju?

Ostao ti relation/10476957#map=12/44.6238/20.4541

Da menjam u Dini isto?

No need, it's not that big of an error. My comment was more in the spirit "hey, this thing exist, do not blindly change street names:D"

So, on main site, you navigate to "Ulice" (streets), then to "Dnevni izvestaj" (daily report), then pick municipality (admin_level=8 basically) and inside pick settlement (admin_level=9). There is street listing (which you can order, filter...). Clicking on street name in second column you will have geometries of cadastre street (red color) and conflated OSM street (blue color). On each page in DINA, there is "Pomoc" in top menu which is different for every page and explains that page. We already imported and fixed all streets as you can see (97% done and rest of 3% is mostly impossible due to cadastre errors). Let me know for any questions you might have!

Zdravo, izmenio sam perone 11-20 da budu malo vise po pravilima (cini mi se, gledao sam Berlinsku stanicu). Tj. izbrisao sam "peron" ime sa ulice i stavio na area-u i stavio ga i na stop_position. Ako ti je ok, uradio bih to i za perone 1-10

Zdravo,
Da li znas za DINA alat? https://dina.openstreetmap.rs Tu imamo zvanicne geometrije ulica i po tome smo uradili celu Srbiju. Imamo i nasu podlogu gde mogu da se vide RGZ ulice. Ovo sto si sad dodao ime na zapadni krak nije bas Viogorska - ni po geometriji, ni po zgradama sa te zapadne strane. Ostavio sam, ne bih da brisem, nego da znas za ubuduce da imamo alat gde mozemo da proverimo geometrije ulica! Hvala
---
Hi,
Do you know for DINA platform? https://dina.openstreetmap.rs There we have street geoemetries and this is how we fixed whole Serbia. We also have our own layer where you can see RGZ (cadastre) streets. Name you added on west part of this street is not technically Viogorska - neither from geometry nor looking at surrounding buildings on that west side. I left it as-is, but you should know that we have this tool where we can check street geometries. Thanks!

I hope we already discussed *not* adding road names in Serbia?

And, c'mon, do you really think there is road named "Nirvana road"? With all other roads being in cyrillic and in serbian language? How old some kid needs to be to fool you this easily?

Heya, both of these are part of same class of issues - "there is named highway, but it is not in RGZ, so what to do with it" (name:en and name:ru are just collateral here, question is "should name exist at all"). I am planning to start bigger discussion on forum, but trying to cleanup as much as I can.

Regarding bridge, there is no RGZ highway for street there. So, I was thinking we should remove "name" completely from highways on the bridge and keep it only on relation: relation/2670239. Same situations is with other bridges in Belgrade and Novi Sad. But this is too big of change, so I am collecting all cases and my plan is to ask on forum. As you see, I kept name:en on relation of bridge itself.

Regarding "Polasci", this was error on my side, I fixed it now. I tried really hard *not* to delete name:ru and name:en from bus station, as I think it can be really helpful (as you can see, all other name:en and name:ru are still there, both Прибытия and Отправления). Now, this is also same class of problems (should they be named or not), but for this, it is far easier to say "yes, who cares about RGZ here, this is needed". Again, I still plan to bring this to forum, same as "Milos veliki" highway that also is not in RGZ etc (lot of other classes of cases)

Oh, it was my mistake, I didn't check history properly. Sorry for my comment and for causing you inconvenience!

OK, nije tvoj hir, stvarno nešto postoji!:)

Evo napravio sam relaciju (to je malo napredniji koncept u OSM-u, ali to je najprecizniji način da se obeležavaju ovako hiking/bici putevi i sl.):
relation/19987469

Nazvao sam je Sotska, međutim ovaj vrh me je naveo da se zove "Šot", pogledaj molim te da li treba da se on popravlja: node/6683556480

Tu sam za pitanja ili ako hoćeš još nešto da popraviš mapu!

Zdravo Ćiro,
Da li ova staza ima zvanično ime ovako ili si ti smislio? Ako nema ime, izbrisao bih ime sa staze (a naravno ostavio stazu). Ako je neka staza koja postoji negde (bilo kakav sajt, planinarski savez, lokalni časopis koji je pominje), onda bih napravio relaciju (tako se u OSM-uz označavaju duži objekti) i nazvao je Sotska. I još jedno pitanje - verovatno je "Šotska", a na "Sotska", ali da proverim?

You just created vandalism. There is no such thing as "mazin blok", someone is just toying with you. If you knew language, you would know... also you are not looking at government open data, I am not sure how many times we need to tell you to NOT add/change street names

Dogovor je da ne nazivamo puteve svojevoljno, nego da pratimo RGZ. Mesto Zaugline postoji, nalazi se severno do Drine. Ovo što si ti uneo nije blizu tog mesta, nema ga u RGZ-u i nema ref:RS:ulica. Odakle ti informacije za ove ulice što unosiš? Jel ima neka tabla da se ulica ovde zove tako? Moramo da se dogovorimo, nije normalno da ja idem i brišem imena puteva, a ti ih onda dodaješ:)

https://dina.openstreetmap.rs/st/opstine/bajinabasta/ZAUGLINE.html

Ma nije problem, sve što uradiš se ceni! Ako imaš nekih pitanja, ili hoćeš da ćaskaš sa ostalim "entuzijastima koji vole geografiju", nađi nas na telegramu ili forumu:)

Zdravo,
Samo da ti javim da ne stavljamo imena na staze i puteve koji nisu u RGZ-u oznaceni tim imenom, ili da imaju neku lokalnu tablu (tj. da je ime zvanicno). Imamo izvestaj na sajtu DINA: https://dina.openstreetmap.rs/ gde se trudimo da imamo unete sve kucne brojeve i ulice, i da to odrzavamo. Tu smo i na forumu i na telegram grupi, pa svrni ako hoces ili bi nesto da pitas. Koliko vidim, sve sto radis po Pozarevcu je super (ako si pocetnik - svaka cast!), samo sam hteo ovo da napomenem