OpenStreetMap logo OpenStreetMap

One-upping other map providers...

Posted by dónal on 27 June 2021 in English.

Changset ID # 107053042

Cork County Council in conjunction with TII (Ireland’s authority for major roads) are in the process of building a bypass past Macroom and Ballyvourney in Co. Cork, Ireland.

Recently, I was travelling back from Killarney and noted that the road had been re-aligned. I quickly captured some GPD traces and have now updated OpenStreetMap with the new roundabout and re-aligned N22 (the bypass will assume the N22 name I presume when it opens).

This was a relatively nice edit to undertake. While I only had one trace to work with, it was good enough to get a rough idea of what needed to change. I also had to amend the N22 route relation(s) - there were two; one in each direction. I didn’t have a whole lot of experience editing these types of relations but the josm interface was intuitive.

As always, I wanted to validate my work (especially as I was editing a primary national route in Ireland). ra.osmsurround.org is a great tool for that so I checked both relations for issues (see relations 3147725 and 558006).

I expect more changes in the coming months as work progresses on this road.

Finally, I checked to see if other map providers had picked up on the change. Funnily enough it appears that Google have picked up on it (possibly using data from Google Maps’ users) but in much lower detail. I guess their algorithms detect something is up but don’t know how to deal with it properly yet. 1-0 to OpenStreetMap!

p.s. Driving round the roundabout 3-4 times was quite fun and a great way to get a good trace for it.

Images

Roundabout on OpenStreetMap Roundabout on Google Maps

Location: Carrigaphooca, Kilnamartery, Municipal District of Macroom, County Cork, Munster, Ireland

Discussion

Comment from DeBigC on 28 June 2021 at 11:07

Although I don’t think it arises in this case the principle of “latest is greatest” is a good one to adopt when copying GPS traces. You can’t ultimately rely on some GPS data, so I also use Mapillary, since the GPS on those are somewhat superior to what I see on the “early days” GPS traces laying around.

It is good that you did this. Navigators often go into a spin when a locations differ from the route data, you have ensured that the osm based ones will not, at least not in this location.

Log in to leave a comment